Thursday, April 23, 2009

Leaving the Berkeley bubble

Yesterday I was a little fragile, a little peevish and petulant. I'm on vacation, so I should be enjoying myself - which made me even more upset. What was making me so irritated?

While driving around, 'spoza and I had a little conversation, trying to get at the source of my irritation, and I think she found it: leaving the Berkeley bubble is confronting me with the hard fact that millions of people choose to live differently than I'd like to live.

The good people of Utah, speaking generally and not specifically, like living large. Large houses, large cars, large portions of food. Acres and acres of anonymous McMansions, hermetically sealed by covenant-compliant white plastic fences. Wide roads packed with king cab pickup trucks on stilts. Restaurants which pride themselves on maximizing caloric value per dollar. Design and forethought seems to be much less important than quantity.

The frustrating thing for me is that when we moved to Berkeley, I vowed not to become a Berkeley snob, and now I find I've started to become one. Berkeley-ites, when they discovered I had just come from Utah, were very dismissive. They implied that I must be overjoyed to have escaped oppression and mediocrity when I left Utah. In Berkeley, it's almost axiomatic that all the people living in flyover country are insipid and narrow-minded, as opposed to the accomplished, internationally experienced Bay Area.

The truth was that I was very happy living in Utah. After having lived so many places growing up, I pride myself on my adaptability - I've enjoyed living in the Mojave Desert and Siberia, in the Pacific Northwest and the Great Basin, even in the ruthless, unrelenting sun of Los Angeles (ok, so maybe LA was my least favorite place to live. =) So I interpreted Berkeley snobbery as Bay Area parochialism. I still think that the Bay Area tends to make people rather parochial, despite its pretensions to internationalism. But the difficult truth is that I really like a lot of things about Berkeley, and I've started taking it for granted. I like living around people which value the environment, and understand that bigger is not always better. I like restaurants that serve me moderate portions of exquisitely crafted food. I like seeing ZENN neighborhood electric vehicles on the roads. I like walking to Trader Joe's.

It's hard to be confronted with so many square miles of sprawling evidence that other people don't value these things, and I think that's what made me so irritable yesterday. I'm reexamining my prized adaptability - could I really be happy living here?

Ironically, I was lifted out of my funk by large quantities of anonymous pizza - it was a great value, only $6 for a pizza and a prodigious order of breadsticks, accompanied by all the HFCS I could stand. And right now I'm relaxing on an enormous couch inside a gargantuan house with enough square footage to lose my glasses in thousands of different ways. There is a certain mindset from which I could enjoy all of this. Perhaps that's what really irked me. =)

7 comments:

  1. Excellently written! I think you perfectly captured the angst I, and many Berkeley-loving Utahns, feel when thinking of moving back. Sometimes I deeply miss my Utah home and family and think about how lovely it would be to return. But...yes, how would I deal with the super-sized consumerism culture? Could I live there without looking down my nose at my Escalade-owning neighbors? Could I go to church without snickering at the abundant blond highlights? Could I refrain from judging the tendency to be judgmental?

    I wonder if I could be a good person in Utah. Though it shouldn't be this way, it seems so much easier to forgive the imperfections of others when they aren't church members. And oddly, considering it is the motherland of my religion, I wonder whether I could keep strong my personal values and priorities. Because...as you wrote, oh, that large square footage sounds seductive.

    ReplyDelete
  2. .

    Oh, you speak the truth the truth the truth. I don't even know what to add to it. Except I really don't want to leave.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think I could have written this post (not so eloquently, but with the same fervor!!). This is exactly how we've been feeling on these rotations. We haven't seen any walkable neighborhoods and people are more concerned with "cheap" than "healthy" or "good quality". Hopefully us Berkeley-ites will be able to spread the knowledge we've gained to our new communities (and find a way to be happy!).

    ReplyDelete
  4. I really enjoyed your post, but I don't think I enjoyed it for the same reasons as most of your other readers. Your description of the perceived Bay Area snobbery is exactly the reason I ultimately decided to stay in Utah for law school!

    When I went to visit law schools in the area, it wasn't uncommon for fellow admitted students or professors from the school to ask the question, "so, where did you do your undergrad?" When I answered that I went to BYU in Utah, the response was often a wry smile that gave the impression they wanted to pat me on the head and say "well, isn't that cute."

    For all that I love about CA, and for all that I hated about UT growing up, I've come to appreciate each. I love California for the quirky way it embraces causes and passionately defends them. I have also come to be happy here in Utah, despite the McMansions, SUVs, and super-sized gut-blaster food.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Reading this from soulless, enormous, unwalkable, and sprawling Las Vegas all I can say is you are so very right. and well-written :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi, grandson. Your article leaves me a little puzzled. For someone with your brains to paint all fly over country people with the same brush surprises me. I think you may have lived in the Berkley environment too long.
    Grandpa Cat

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hi Grandpa -
    Thanks for stopping by my blog. I definitely don't mean to paint everyone in flyover country with the same brush. I have met amazing, brilliant, interesting people everywhere I've lived. My complaints about Utah are more with cultural values than with specific people. I still believe Utah culture places too much emphasis on quantity rather than quality. I believe these values lead to a lot of problems, like obesity, and carelessness towards the Earth we've been given stewardship over. In addition, I just dislike the aesthetics of a culture devoted to size rather than beauty - I find it irritating.

    I have another set of problems which irritate me about Berkeley and the cultural values that predominate here, but that's for another post. =)

    Thanks again for stopping by.

    ReplyDelete